In the annals of human delusion, few fictions have been as stubbornly maintained as the notion of a Palestinian state—a chimera born of 20th-century geopolitics, nursed by Arab despots, and sustained by the West's guilty conscience. It is May 2025, and the dream lies in ashes, as it always deserved to.
Gaza, that festering sore on the Mediterranean, is no more—a rubble-strewn testament to the futility of its own aspirations. The West Bank, a patchwork of Israeli control and Palestinian resentment, stands as the last relic of what could have been, a mausoleum for a people who never understood the first rule of history: survival demands more than savagery.
Let us dispense with the sentimental claptrap that has long clouded this issue. The Palestinians do not want a country, nor do they seek peace. Their history is a litany of rejection—1947, 2000, 2008—each opportunity for statehood spurned with the petulance of a child who demands the moon. The Oslo Accords, those naive scribblings of a more hopeful age, were met with the Second Intifada, a campaign of suicide bombings that left 1,000 Israelis dead and the dream of coexistence in tatters.
The 2023 Hamas assault, a barbaric spree that claimed 1,195 lives, many of them progressive Jews who dared to employ Palestinians in their homes, was the final nail in the coffin. These workers, granted access through a black-market permit system, repaid kindness with betrayal, sharing intelligence that led to the slaughter of entire families in Kibbutz Be'eri and Kfar Azza. By what perverse logic should such a people be granted the dignity of nationhood?
The genetic argument, too, collapses under scrutiny. The Palestinians are not a distinct people, as their advocates claim, but a fragment of the Levantine continuum, sharing 95-98% of their DNA with Syrians, Lebanese, and Jordanians. Studies from the 1000 Genomes Project reveal an Fst value—a measure of genetic differentiation—of a mere 0.002 to 0.005 between Palestinians and Syrians, closer than the French and Germans.
Their ancestry, rooted in the Natufians and Canaanites, is indistinguishable from their neighbors, a fact that renders their claim to ethnic uniqueness as hollow as their political aspirations. They are Syrians by blood, Arabs by culture, and Palestinians only by the accident of modern borders—a construct as artificial as the Green Line they so bitterly contest.
But it is their moral failure that damns them most. On October 7, 2023, Hamas, with the complicity of Palestinian workers, stained the floors of Jewish homes with blood—floors they were paid to clean, earning $1,500 monthly in a land where their own economy offers a pittance of $600-$800. These were not the wages of oppression but of pragmatism, a lifeline extended by a state they sought to destroy.
The victims, many of whom opposed Netanyahu and advocated for Gaza, were repaid with murder, their trust exploited by those who reject Israel's very right to exist. And now, Gaza is gone—its 2 million inhabitants scattered or buried beneath the rubble of their own making, a consequence of 28,000 rockets fired since that fateful day, as Human Rights Watch grimly tallies. Israel's response, a campaign of unrelenting force, has left the enclave a ghost, its dreams of resistance extinguished.
The West Bank remains, a fractured landscape of 695,000 Israeli settlers and a Palestinian Authority that governs in name only. It is a de facto one-state reality, where Israel's dominance ensures survival—a necessity, lest the region descend into the sectarian chaos of Lebanon's civil war.
Ramallah persists as a Palestinian enclave, but its autonomy is a mirage, overshadowed by Israeli checkpoints and the looming presence of settlements. This is all that remains of the Palestinian idea: a memory of what could have been, had they chosen coexistence over carnage.
To speak of their worthiness is to indulge in a bitter irony. A people who have bathed in the blood of those who offered them work, who have rejected every chance at peace, who cling to a fabricated identity while their genetic brothers thrive in neighboring states—such a people are not fit to clean the floors they have defiled, let alone govern a nation.
The West Bank will be their epitaph, a reminder of a cause that was never just, never viable, and never theirs to claim. Israel endures, as it must, a bulwark against the barbarism that surrounds it. To suggest otherwise is to invite calamity, a lesson the world has learned at a cost too terrible to repeat.
F I N I S
Citations & Archives
[01] Genetic Distance: 1000 Genomes Project - Levantine Analysis
[02] Verification: HRW Verified Rocket Tally (28,000 Units)
[03] Demographics: CBS Area C Settlement Report 2024
